Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
+3
Tsunayoshi
MK_ultra
twosoul
7 posters
Page 1 of 1
Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
hi, i wanted to say that the Magical Diemnsion has got a wrong card text.
Card text on TCG card game:
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Errata:Magical_Dimension
Card text on DLNW:
The different is "and";"then" in card text.
Thanks 4 reading!
Card text on TCG card game:
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Errata:Magical_Dimension
You can only activate this card while there is a face-up Spellcaster-Type monster(s) on your side of the field. Tribute 1 monster on your side of the field and Special Summon 1 Spellcaster-Type monster from your hand. Then you can destroy 1 monster on the field.
Card text on DLNW:
If you control a face-up Spellcaster-Type monster: Target 1 monster you control; Tribute it, then Special Summon 1 Spellcaster-Type monster from your hand, then you can destroy 1 monster on the field.
The different is "and";"then" in card text.
Thanks 4 reading!
twosoul- Posts : 6
Join date : 2011-10-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
youre complaning about this? wow i remember when i was 5 and complaned about why the sun was hot
MK_ultra- Posts : 620
Join date : 2011-11-03
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
With "and" i can combo magical dimension+Fortune Lady Light.
With "then" i can't!
So,Are You have to understand why i think seriously?
With "then" i can't!
So,Are You have to understand why i think seriously?
twosoul- Posts : 6
Join date : 2011-10-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
twosoul wrote:With "and" i can combo magical dimension+Fortune Lady Light.
With "then" i can't!
So,Are You have to understand why i think seriously?
Card text will NOT be changed. The text you claim is wrong is the official card text with the new problem solving language.
Tsunayoshi- Posts : 1915
Birthday : 1987-09-27
Join date : 2011-08-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
Sorry!i'm wrong .Card text in TU06 (Latest errata) is "then".
Thanks you!
Thanks you!
twosoul- Posts : 6
Join date : 2011-10-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
twosoul wrote:Sorry!i'm wrong .Card text in TU06 (Latest errata) is "then".
Thanks you!
Also as another point before this thread has no need to be posted again. FL Light doesnt mix well at all with Magical Dimension because of the extra destruction effect of MD, which would prevent Light from using its effect even if the text did say 'and'
Tsunayoshi- Posts : 1915
Birthday : 1987-09-27
Join date : 2011-08-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
If the text say "and",when i active effect MD by tributing FL Light,the first effect of MD and effect of FL light apply Simultaneous.But,because the second effect of MD is Optional trigger effect,if i choose active this effect=>FL Light miss timing.
If i don't choose active=>FL Light isn't miss timing.
However,It does not matter.
P/S:Sorry,My English is very bad!
If i don't choose active=>FL Light isn't miss timing.
However,It does not matter.
P/S:Sorry,My English is very bad!
twosoul- Posts : 6
Join date : 2011-10-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
Not necessary simultaneous, look at Polymerizationtwosoul wrote:If the text say "and",when i active effect MD by tributing FL Light,the first effect of MD and effect of FL light apply Simultaneous.
Key- ←↓Ruling Scrubbie↑→
- Posts : 2608
Birthday : 1994-11-29
Join date : 2011-05-21
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
Key wrote:Not necessary simultaneous, look at Polymerizationtwosoul wrote:If the text say "and",when i active effect MD by tributing FL Light,the first effect of MD and effect of FL light apply Simultaneous.
Possibly the reason for the change from 'and' to 'then'
Tsunayoshi- Posts : 1915
Birthday : 1987-09-27
Join date : 2011-08-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
Would light's effect activate if I destroyed her with the "then you can destroy 1 monster on the field" part?
LuzCeleste- Posts : 878
Birthday : 1990-01-14
Join date : 2011-10-01
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
Nope. Last thing to happen would not be Light leaving the field.
Tsunayoshi- Posts : 1915
Birthday : 1987-09-27
Join date : 2011-08-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
What would be the last thing happening then? ._.
Didn't I tribute something... Then summoned something.... Then destroyed light? What happens after that?
Didn't I tribute something... Then summoned something.... Then destroyed light? What happens after that?
LuzCeleste- Posts : 878
Birthday : 1990-01-14
Join date : 2011-10-01
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
LuzCeleste wrote:What would be the last thing happening then? ._.
Didn't I tribute something... Then summoned something.... Then destroyed light? What happens after that?
I can finally answer a ruling question!!!! I'm so certain if you were to destroy Fortune Lady Light per Magical Dimension's last effect, you'd get to SS a Darky, Watery, Earthy, or even Firey!!!!! If there is something else going on in the background, someone please let me know, but from what I understand, it's just because Fortune Lady Lights being sent to the graveyard is the last to resolve, just like how it would be the last to resolve if she were to get Fissure'd.
I'm posting the magical dimension card to make any further debates easier... I might be wrong, but when I played in Tag Force 5, and I did that(ex. Fortune Lady Light and dark magician on field, Tribute dark magician to SS Dark Magician of Chaos, then destroy Fortune Lady Light)I was able to SS another Fortune Lady to the Field.
I hope i'm right because I was really looking forward to being able to help someone!!!
exiled_force- Posts : 227
Join date : 2011-10-31
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
exiled_force wrote:LuzCeleste wrote:What would be the last thing happening then? ._.
Didn't I tribute something... Then summoned something.... Then destroyed light? What happens after that?
I can finally answer a ruling question!!!! I'm so certain if you were to destroy Fortune Lady Light per Magical Dimension's last effect, you'd get to SS a Darky, Watery, Earthy, or even Firey!!!!! If there is something else going on in the background, someone please let me know, but from what I understand, it's just because Fortune Lady Lights being sent to the graveyard is the last to resolve, just like how it would be the last to resolve if she were to get Fissure'd.
I'm posting the magical dimension card to make any further debates easier... I might be wrong, but when I played in Tag Force 5, and I did that(ex. Fortune Lady Light and dark magician on field, Tribute dark magician to SS Dark Magician of Chaos, then destroy Fortune Lady Light)I was able to SS another Fortune Lady to the Field.
I hope i'm right because I was really looking forward to being able to help someone!!!
Previous,card text say:"....Tribute it,and Special summon...".So,if you do not destroy monster by second effect of Magical dimension.you can act eff dimension and FL light Simultaneous,because the last thing to happen would be Light leaving the field.
If you active the second effect of Dimension,destroy 1 monster.The last thing to happen would be MD destroy 1 monster=>FL Light effect is miss timing.
But Currently,card text change to:"....Tribute it,then Special Summon...".So,you can not act effect FL Light because the first effect of dimension and FL light doest not Simultaneous (FL light effect is miss timing),even you do not active optinal effect of magical dimension.
twosoul- Posts : 6
Join date : 2011-10-22
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
twosoul wrote:exiled_force wrote:LuzCeleste wrote:What would be the last thing happening then? ._.
Didn't I tribute something... Then summoned something.... Then destroyed light? What happens after that?
I can finally answer a ruling question!!!! I'm so certain if you were to destroy Fortune Lady Light per Magical Dimension's last effect, you'd get to SS a Darky, Watery, Earthy, or even Firey!!!!! If there is something else going on in the background, someone please let me know, but from what I understand, it's just because Fortune Lady Lights being sent to the graveyard is the last to resolve, just like how it would be the last to resolve if she were to get Fissure'd.
I'm posting the magical dimension card to make any further debates easier... I might be wrong, but when I played in Tag Force 5, and I did that(ex. Fortune Lady Light and dark magician on field, Tribute dark magician to SS Dark Magician of Chaos, then destroy Fortune Lady Light)I was able to SS another Fortune Lady to the Field.
I hope i'm right because I was really looking forward to being able to help someone!!!
Previous,card text say:"....Tribute it,and Special summon...".So,if you do not destroy monster by second effect of Magical dimension.you can act eff dimension and FL light Simultaneous,because the last thing to happen would be Light leaving the field.
If you active the second effect of Dimension,destroy 1 monster.The last thing to happen would be MD destroy 1 monster=>FL Light effect is miss timing.
But Currently,card text change to:"....Tribute it,then Special Summon...".So,you can not act effect FL Light because the first effect of dimension and FL light doest not Simultaneous (FL light effect is miss timing),even you do not active optinal effect of magical dimension.
Ok... From what I understand, here's how it works.
Effect 1:Tribute Monster
Choose something other then Fortune Lady Light, like another monster on the field(doesn't have to be spellcaster-type.
Effect 2:Special Summon Monster
Now choose a monster from your hand if it can be special summoned. If you were to choose Fortune Lady Light originally, it wouldn't work simply because she is being tributed, whereas she needs to be destroyed or removed from the field via card effect.
Effect 3:Destroy a monster.
This is the question LuzCeleste seemed to have. A monster is now being destroyed. The only way Fortune Lady Light's effect would not activate is if she was chosen as the intial tribute fodder, unless you had two Fortune Lady Lights' to begin with. At this time, it is the same way as being treated as Fortune Lady Light being fissure'd, hammer shot'd, or Dark Hole'd. She is leaving the field via a card effect, and this is the last effect to resolve, so because it is the last thing to happen, her SS effect should activate should you choose to.
The only point in which Fortune Lady Light would "Miss the Timing" is if she were to leave the field first as the initial effect, and then the rest of the three effects of this card were to resolve. So to answer your question, Fortune Lady does not work well with the first effect of Magical Dimension, only the third and final effect. So in other words, it would be good for special summoning two monsters.
exiled_force- Posts : 227
Join date : 2011-10-31
Re: Magical Dimension got wrong card text!!!
LuzCeleste wrote:Would light's effect activate if I destroyed her with the "then you can destroy 1 monster on the field" part?
Yes you can, destroying is indeed the last thing to happen
Thanax42- Posts : 122
Birthday : 1988-11-12
Join date : 2011-09-11
Similar topics
» Sacred Ptolemys M7 got wrong card text
» Magical Dimension
» Yu-Gi-Oh! New Logo Text Card
» What do you think about the new card text style?
» Breaker the Magical Warrior/ Card Guard rulings
» Magical Dimension
» Yu-Gi-Oh! New Logo Text Card
» What do you think about the new card text style?
» Breaker the Magical Warrior/ Card Guard rulings
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum