Honest's Return Effect

In my actual dueling experiences, I thought that you could summon Honest on your first main phase, conduct battle with it, and finally on the second main phase return it to your hand.

I have done that with no problem, but in a duel that I had on Dueling Network tonight, someone told me that I could not do that. He told me that I had to wait on my next turn. I looked at the Wikia on this and there was nothing.

Am I correct or was my opponent and where is the ruling for this anyway?

u're correct

You were right. There doesn't even need to be a ruling for it, there's nothing in the card text that states Honest cannot return to the hand via its own effect if it had battled that turn.

BlackwoodCompany wrote:In my actual dueling experiences, I thought that you could summon Honest on your first main phase, conduct battle with it, and finally on the second main phase return it to your hand.

I have done that with no problem, but in a duel that I had on Dueling Network tonight, someone told me that I could not do that. He told me that I had to wait on my next turn. I looked at the Wikia on this and there was nothing.

Am I correct or was my opponent and where is the ruling for this anyway?

Who is this someone ?
Definitely a netdecker who thiking that he can remove a monster after attacking with BLS/Chaos Sorcorer

On honest topic, you are correct, you can summon in MP , attack in BP and return in M2

People need to start actually paying attention to those things on cards. What're they called again? Words?

Tuvillo wrote:People need to start actually paying attention to those things on cards. What're they called again? Words?

You seem to be implying they're even reading the cards in the first place.

How silly.

DefiniteOtaku wrote:

Tuvillo wrote:People need to start actually aying attention to those things on cards. What're they called again? Words?

You seem to be implying they're even reading the cards in the first place.

How silly.

Problem y r u normalling honest in the first place?

kangtuji wrote:

BlackwoodCompany wrote:In my actual dueling experiences, I thought that you could summon Honest on your first main phase, conduct battle with it, and finally on the second main phase return it to your hand.

I have done that with no problem, but in a duel that I had on Dueling Network tonight, someone told me that I could not do that. He told me that I had to wait on my next turn. I looked at the Wikia on this and there was nothing.

Am I correct or was my opponent and where is the ruling for this anyway?

Who is this someone ?
Definitely a netdecker who thiking that he can remove a monster after attacking with BLS/Chaos Sorcorer

On honest topic, you are correct, you can summon in MP , attack in BP and return in M2

this comment makes literally 0 sense...stop posting please

DefiniteOtaku wrote:

Tuvillo wrote:People need to start actually paying attention to those things on cards. What're they called again? Words?

You seem to be implying they're even reading the cards in the first place.

How silly.

Trust me I Baby sit public Chat....

9/10 of the questions are something in the text of the card An Example of this is.....


"Can Solemn warning negate a normal summon"

.....

I see Laggia vs Flip Summons a lot, and neither side has a problem with it when it DOES negate it.

They never read the card, they always think that Laggia is a Spell Speed 2 Solemn Judgment, so they assume it can negate Flip Summon, although it actually can't.