Dueling Network Forums
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

+3
Badass_Bunny
Eliwood
CEMO
7 posters

Go down

Solved Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  CEMO 2012-01-10, 01:27

I've seen this come up a few times and I'm curious as to what the ruling should be.

Gem-Knight Citrine's effect states "If this card battles, your opponent cannot activate the effects of Spell, Trap, or Effect Monsters until the end of the Damage Step."

The issue I see is the timing for "until the end of the Damage Step." Does this mean when the whole Damage Step is competely over or does it mean at the SubStep 7 part of the Battle Phase called "End of the Damage Step" as posted here: http://forum.duelingnetwork.com/t2754-ruling-faq-clearing-up-the-most-confusable-rulings#bp?

If it's the former then Sangan's effect would not activate. But if Citrine's effect only applies until Substep 7 then I believe Sangan's effect should be activated.

I looked on the wiki but there's no actual ruling for Citrine. Only Tips. So I'd like to hear what the mods here will rule it as.

Thanks in advance
CEMO
CEMO


Posts : 6
Join date : 2012-01-04

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  Eliwood 2012-01-10, 01:39

@Does this mean when the whole Damage Step is competely over-
yes

@If it's the former then Sangan's effect would not activate.
This is correct.
Eliwood
Eliwood


Posts : 620
Birthday : 1992-01-13
Join date : 2011-10-04

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  Badass_Bunny 2012-01-10, 02:20

Nope Sangan and anything of sort will not activate in this case.
Badass_Bunny
Badass_Bunny
Smexy Duelist
Smexy Duelist

Posts : 2660
Birthday : 1996-04-17
Join date : 2011-06-12

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  RareHunter 2012-01-10, 04:54

Condition
- Citrine on field
- Sangan set mode on field
- enter Battle Phase. Citrine attack Sangan (decleare attack)
- Sangan flipped
- enter damage Step Citrine (ATK 2200), Sangan (DEF 600)
- enter damage calculation (2200-600)
- damage calculation end, damage step end, sangan destroyed and sent to grave

So, Sangan effect activated.

CMIIW
RareHunter
RareHunter


Posts : 921
Birthday : 1992-08-16
Join date : 2011-05-20

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  kangtuji 2012-01-10, 05:20

Sangan active with same timing as mytic tomatoes (destroyed, send to grave, and active) Its happen During damage step
and citrine eff do states "If this card battles, your opponent cannot activate the effects of Spell, Trap, or Effect Monsters until the end of the Damage Step."

The question should arise is... can citrine attack got negated ?
Someone else has questioning if battle =/= declaring attack (not yet battling)
kangtuji
kangtuji


Posts : 1611
Join date : 2011-07-31

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  BlackwingRa 2012-01-10, 06:08

Declaring an attack is the 1st step for Citrine's effect to apply.
BlackwingRa
BlackwingRa


Posts : 832
Birthday : 1991-10-02
Join date : 2011-05-19

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  Badass_Bunny 2012-01-10, 06:32

No the attack can't be negated.
Anything that activates when destroyed by battle is negated.
Everything that activates as result of being flipped face up is negated.
Anything that activates as result of an attack declaration is negated.
Anything that activates when sent to grave is negated.
Badass_Bunny
Badass_Bunny
Smexy Duelist
Smexy Duelist

Posts : 2660
Birthday : 1996-04-17
Join date : 2011-06-12

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  CEMO 2012-01-10, 16:27

Thanks for the responses. I'm assuming that Badass_Bunny is correct unless there's a ruling that says otherwise. May I ask why RareHunter's explanation is not correct just so that I can understand the process of how it all happens.

RareHunter wrote:Condition
- Citrine on field
- Sangan set mode on field
- enter Battle Phase. Citrine attack Sangan (decleare attack)
- Sangan flipped
- enter damage Step Citrine (ATK 2200), Sangan (DEF 600)
- enter damage calculation (2200-600)
- damage calculation end, damage step end, sangan destroyed and sent to grave

So, Sangan effect activated.

CMIIW

That way if it comes up again I will be able to explain why the "until the end of the Damage Step" part of Citrine's effect does not refer to the SubStep 7 part called "End of Damage Step."

Again, thank you for clearing this up for me
CEMO
CEMO


Posts : 6
Join date : 2012-01-04

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  Joenen 2012-01-10, 16:43

sangan's effect activates during the damage step, just like a mystic tomato would.

Citrine forbids all effects from activating during the damage step.

so naturally sangan will not activate as citrine forbids it.

Joenen
Joenen


Posts : 91
Birthday : 1992-04-08
Join date : 2011-08-23

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  Badass_Bunny 2012-01-10, 16:51

No all cards that say "Until The End Of Damage Step" refer to all 7 substeps of damage step, including the last 7th step.
Badass_Bunny
Badass_Bunny
Smexy Duelist
Smexy Duelist

Posts : 2660
Birthday : 1996-04-17
Join date : 2011-06-12

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  CEMO 2012-01-10, 18:15

Oh okay, thank you
CEMO
CEMO


Posts : 6
Join date : 2012-01-04

Back to top Go down

Solved Re: Gem-Knight Citrine VS Sangan

Post  Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum