Morphing Jar 2..Do You Remember..?

Hello..

I'm jbakura87.Here, i would like you to review to something i faced recently

I've duel with a duelist and got this problem..i ll explained it one by one..

1. in his Main Phase, i had 1 monster and he had 1 faced down monster (morphing jar 2)
2. he flip summonned than morphing jar and return it to deck, i also return my 1 monster
3. after shuffling deck,he milled from his deck and got 1 lv4 monster so it is sp summoned faced down
4. i also shuffling n milled..then i got 1 monster (vampire lord lv5 atk 2000) picked up to the grave..i left it there in graveyard since it cannot be sp summoned
5. following the rule, i don't have to mill since i already pick up than 1 monster..

but the problem is

1. the opponent ask me to continue mill until i get monster lv4 or less. (this is wrong).Then, i refuse and explained he wrong
2. he said i m cheating and will call mod
3. i ask him to call mod and dissapoint, the mod also want me to continue mill until i get monster with lv4 or less..and said dont waste his time

Then, i wondering..was the mod he said really professional in this game..?..why don't he
know the effect of morphing jar 2..?..i felt like i m being cheated and being banned after that..is that ok being banned as i stand the ruling of that card..?(morphing jar2)..

I hope, this might be reviewed carefully..Thank You

Is Morphing Jar 2 a difficult card to be understand..?..do you remember the effect,hehe..

EDIT by DJD

Http://images.wikia.com/yugioh/images/6/68/MorphingJar2DB1-EN-R-UE.jpg

FLIP: Return all Monster Cards on the field to their respective Decks and shuffle them. You and your opponent then pick up cards until you both have the same number of Monster Cards that were returned to each Deck. Special Summon the Level 4 or lower monsters to the field in face-down Defense Position. The rest of the cards picked up are discarded to the Graveyard

Potus Mat, Mill Master.
When MJ2 is flipped, all monsters return to the deck (or Extra deck or Banished, depending on the conditions). Then, both players pick up (NOT DRAW) cards until they pick up the same number of monsters returned to their main deck. All Level Four and lower monsters that can be Normal Summoned are Special Summoned in face-down defense position, and all other cards are sent to the Graveyard.

First off I'd like for you to know that double posting is not allowed on this forum. If you wish to add more to your first post later on you can simply edit it in. I've taken the liberty to do so for you since you are new and are probably not familiar with the rules.

I'm also not sure if you are trying to report a player and mod or if you are simply trying to confirm Morphing Jar 2's effect. If you are trying to report the moderator that wasn't professional with you we'll need for you to tell us their user name, and if possible provide us with a screen shot showing the conversation you shared with him.

When it comes to Morphing Jar 2, you are correct.

You returned one monster with MJ2's effect meaning you needed to pick up cards until you had one monster; regardless of its level. You drew the one monster, and since it wasn't level four you couldn't special summon it therefore it was discarded. I think your opponent misinterpreted the effect and thought that you had to special summon as many monsters as you returned from the field.

In the future if you ask a mod for help and you are 100% sure that he is wrong be sure to take a screen shot, and report it to another moderator; you can also report them here.

DanceJonDance wrote:First off I'd like for you to know that double posting is not allowed on this forum. If you wish to add more to your first post later on you can simply edit it in. I've taken the liberty to do so for you since you are new and are probably not familiar with the rules.

I'm also not sure if you are trying to report a player and mod or if you are simply trying to confirm Morphing Jar 2's effect. If you are trying to report the moderator that wasn't professional with you we'll need for you to tell us their user name, and if possible provide us with a screen shot showing the conversation you shared with him.

When it comes to Morphing Jar 2, you are correct.

You returned one monster with MJ2's effect meaning you needed to pick up cards until you had one monster; regardless of its level. You drew the one monster, and since it wasn't level four you couldn't special summon it therefore it was discarded. I think your opponent misinterpreted the effect and thought that you had to special summon as many monsters as you returned from the field.

In the future if you ask a mod for help and you are 100% sure that he is wrong be sure to take a screen shot, and report it to another moderator; you can also report them here.

owh,i see..i ll get used to this forum's rule as soon possible.. that happenned for the first time in my duel,so i slipped out to record n take the screen shot or take note any names..i think the other party judge us might be watching users..that situation made me confusing the effect of morphing jar 2 itself whether it has been changed or my duel with yugioh pc games and people around me already obsolete..

tq DanceJonDance

Alright since you got your answer I'm going to lock this and mark it as solved. I'm also moving it to the Ruling Questions area since it's not really a card discussion.

I'm glad I could help.