A bunch of ruling questions
+2
Supreme_King
tester12342
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
A bunch of ruling questions
So I've got a bunch of ruling questions and just decided to stick them all in one thread.
1. Honest vs Honest - I was under the impression that the last one to activate Honest would win the battle but a friend told me that the chain would resolve backwards.
2. Vampire Lord effect - What happens if the opponent has no/runs out of the declared type on his deck to mill? Can the controller of Vampire Lord declare a new type or will the effect just fizzle out?
3. Destiny HERO Diamond Dude - What happens if Diamond Dude mills a spell that stays on the field like Swords of Revealing Light?
4. The Sacred Hyades - Will flip effects activate if The Sacred Hyades uses his effect?
5. Eradicator Epidemic Virus - If the opponent activated Virus and declared Spell Cards and I draw a quick-play spell card on my next turn, I should be able to use the quick-play right?
1. Honest vs Honest - I was under the impression that the last one to activate Honest would win the battle but a friend told me that the chain would resolve backwards.
2. Vampire Lord effect - What happens if the opponent has no/runs out of the declared type on his deck to mill? Can the controller of Vampire Lord declare a new type or will the effect just fizzle out?
3. Destiny HERO Diamond Dude - What happens if Diamond Dude mills a spell that stays on the field like Swords of Revealing Light?
4. The Sacred Hyades - Will flip effects activate if The Sacred Hyades uses his effect?
5. Eradicator Epidemic Virus - If the opponent activated Virus and declared Spell Cards and I draw a quick-play spell card on my next turn, I should be able to use the quick-play right?
tester12342- Posts : 466
Join date : 2011-07-04
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
1. The very fisrt person activating Honest will win. Chain resolving backwards, the last Honest to be activated increases the ATK, then the first Honest will add that attack to the monster.
2. The effect disappears, but you get to look at the opponent's deck to verify that.
3. Only the part of the effect that works when the card is activated will work. So a milled Swords will only flip the monsters, but won't stop the attacks.
4. Yes, they will activate.
5. The effect of Eradicator Epidemic Virus does not start a chain when it activates after a draw. So you cannot activate a Quick-Play Spell card if it's drawn and destroyed by EEV.
2. The effect disappears, but you get to look at the opponent's deck to verify that.
3. Only the part of the effect that works when the card is activated will work. So a milled Swords will only flip the monsters, but won't stop the attacks.
4. Yes, they will activate.
5. The effect of Eradicator Epidemic Virus does not start a chain when it activates after a draw. So you cannot activate a Quick-Play Spell card if it's drawn and destroyed by EEV.
Supreme_King- Hakuna Matata
- Posts : 399
Birthday : 1994-11-25
Join date : 2011-05-18
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
About Honest vs. Honest:
If the 1st Honest is actived before damage calculation, the 2nd Honest can active after, during damage calculation and win.
If the 1st Honest is actived during damage calculation, the 2nd Honest can only chain to 1st Honest and lose.
If the 1st Honest is actived before damage calculation, the 2nd Honest can active after, during damage calculation and win.
If the 1st Honest is actived during damage calculation, the 2nd Honest can only chain to 1st Honest and lose.
Magicknight94- Posts : 161
Join date : 2011-09-13
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
Magicknight94 wrote:About Honest vs. Honest:
If the 1st Honest is actived before damage calculation, the 2nd Honest can active after, during damage calculation and win.
If the 1st Honest is actived during damage calculation, the 2nd Honest can only chain to 1st Honest and lose.
Yeah, my bad not saying that, I just expected a standard Honest vs Honest chain in damage calculation
Supreme_King- Hakuna Matata
- Posts : 399
Birthday : 1994-11-25
Join date : 2011-05-18
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
Thanks a lot. One final question though. Let's say my opponent has Stardust Dragon on the field and I have Grapha, Snoww, Silva and Card Destruction in my hand. Is it possible to arrange the chain in a way that Stardust Dragon will miss timing on Grapha's destruction effect?
tester12342- Posts : 466
Join date : 2011-07-04
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
Yes. SEGOC is one of the most useful ways to stop Stardust and its evolutions.
Magicknight94- Posts : 161
Join date : 2011-09-13
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
How would the chain look like? Is it CL1: Snoww, CL2: Silva, CL3: Grapha or the other way around?
tester12342- Posts : 466
Join date : 2011-07-04
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
when you discard more than 1 DW at a time with card destruction or morphing jar, you can choose the order to resolve their effects.
Broken_Soul- Posts : 510
Birthday : 1988-01-09
Join date : 2011-06-07
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
I know that. I'm asking what order does it need to be for Stardust Dragon's effect to miss timing.Broken_Soul wrote:when you discard more than 1 DW at a time with card destruction or morphing jar, you can choose the order to resolve their effects.
tester12342- Posts : 466
Join date : 2011-07-04
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
Just put Grapha as chain link 1 is ok.
BlackwingRa- Posts : 832
Birthday : 1991-10-02
Join date : 2011-05-19
Re: A bunch of ruling questions
tester12342 wrote:How would the chain look like? Is it CL1: Snoww, CL2: Silva, CL3: Grapha or the other way around?
Actually since all 3 monsters have mandatory effects you can organize them anyway you like. If your trying to kill Stardust Dragon with Grapha, by making it CL 1 or 2, your opponent cannot tribute Stardust to negate it because it is not the last link in the chain.
{EX} TheVoid- Cuddlez's Biscuit
- Posts : 2345
Birthday : 1992-02-29
Join date : 2011-06-22
Similar topics
» Questions about ruling
» inzecter ruling questions
» Multiple Ruling questions
» Abdo's Random Ruling Questions
» My Box of Questions
» inzecter ruling questions
» Multiple Ruling questions
» Abdo's Random Ruling Questions
» My Box of Questions
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum