Questions from me again
+9
Phoenix Wright
Roxzen
mysticgilford101
Kikyo Maaka
Zero2Hero
Badass_Bunny
dest
nelynel12
kumaxtreme
13 posters
Page 1 of 1
Questions from me again
kumaxtreme 2011-07-07, 01:57
The whole purpose of this is to show proof to people who don't know the correct ruling when I'm on DN.
1) I forbidden chalice my opponent Reborn tengu. Later on that turn I destroy tengu. Will he get to special summon?
2)I summon reborn tengu and then a whole turn pass. On my turn my opponent use book of moon on my tengu. Can I flip up my tengu that was set?
3)My opponent only have a field spell in play. Can he be able to drop Gorz? (Had to argue with someone about this a few time.)
4)Explain what happen when synchro or a fusion monster return to the main deck or hand
5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast
6) What is the difference between Lumina and Zombie master? From what I heard Lumina don't need a lightswown monster in the grave to activate it effect.
7)Is Scrap dragon destruction effect have a cost? Does both my card and my opponent card destroy at the same time?
I have royal opression on the field. My opponent use glow up bulb grave effect to summon itself. I negate it by paying 800. Does that effect count to the use only once per duel?
9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien?
1) I forbidden chalice my opponent Reborn tengu. Later on that turn I destroy tengu. Will he get to special summon?
2)I summon reborn tengu and then a whole turn pass. On my turn my opponent use book of moon on my tengu. Can I flip up my tengu that was set?
3)My opponent only have a field spell in play. Can he be able to drop Gorz? (Had to argue with someone about this a few time.)
4)Explain what happen when synchro or a fusion monster return to the main deck or hand
5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast
6) What is the difference between Lumina and Zombie master? From what I heard Lumina don't need a lightswown monster in the grave to activate it effect.
7)Is Scrap dragon destruction effect have a cost? Does both my card and my opponent card destroy at the same time?
I have royal opression on the field. My opponent use glow up bulb grave effect to summon itself. I negate it by paying 800. Does that effect count to the use only once per duel?9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien?
kumaxtreme
- Posts : 25
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-07, 02:21
1) I forbidden chalice my opponent Reborn tengu. Later on that turn I destroy tengu. Will he get to special summon? Yes He will.
2)I summon reborn tengu and then a whole turn pass. On my turn my opponent use book of moon on my tengu. Can I flip up my tengu that was set? If u have not summon him this turn.. yes.
3)My opponent only have a field spell in play. Can he be able to drop Gorz? (Had to argue with someone about this a few time.) No he cannot drop gorz.
4)Explain what happen when synchro or a fusion monster return to the main deck or hand - When it is return to the deck or hand it is sent to the extra deck.
5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast. Yes it does.
6) What is the difference between Lumina and Zombie master? From what I heard Lumina don't need a lightswown monster in the grave to activate it effect. You are correct. Another difference is that Zombie master HAS to remain FACE UP during the resolution or the monster will NOT summon. With lumina, it goes trough regardless.
7)Is Scrap dragon destruction effect have a cost? Does both my card and my opponent card destroy at the same time? It is not a cost. and yes its at the same time
Cool I have royal opression on the field. My opponent use glow up bulb grave effect to summon itself. I negate it by paying 800. Does that effect count to the use only once per duel? Yes it negates it. and glow up bulb cannot activate his efefct again. BTW glow up bulb mill is not a cost.
9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien? No it does not because it was negated.
2)I summon reborn tengu and then a whole turn pass. On my turn my opponent use book of moon on my tengu. Can I flip up my tengu that was set? If u have not summon him this turn.. yes.
3)My opponent only have a field spell in play. Can he be able to drop Gorz? (Had to argue with someone about this a few time.) No he cannot drop gorz.
4)Explain what happen when synchro or a fusion monster return to the main deck or hand - When it is return to the deck or hand it is sent to the extra deck.
5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast. Yes it does.
6) What is the difference between Lumina and Zombie master? From what I heard Lumina don't need a lightswown monster in the grave to activate it effect. You are correct. Another difference is that Zombie master HAS to remain FACE UP during the resolution or the monster will NOT summon. With lumina, it goes trough regardless.
7)Is Scrap dragon destruction effect have a cost? Does both my card and my opponent card destroy at the same time? It is not a cost. and yes its at the same time
Cool I have royal opression on the field. My opponent use glow up bulb grave effect to summon itself. I negate it by paying 800. Does that effect count to the use only once per duel? Yes it negates it. and glow up bulb cannot activate his efefct again. BTW glow up bulb mill is not a cost.
9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien? No it does not because it was negated.
nelynel12
- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
dest 2011-07-07, 06:48
2) If book was used on the attack declaration you may not flip him, else you may flip him.
6) Uhm... I think there isn't a difference. From the rulings page:
6) Uhm... I think there isn't a difference. From the rulings page:
I can't find anything regarding the other differences you might see, but I doubth they are there...You cannot activate "Lumina, Lightsworn Summoner's" effect if you do not have any Level 4 or lower "Lightsworn" monsters in your Graveyard, even if you would discard one to activate the effect.
dest- Boneash
- Posts : 845
Birthday : 1987-07-30
Join date : 2011-06-29
Re: Questions from me again
Badass_Bunny 2011-07-07, 08:39
Yeah Lumina can't activate it's eff if there is no LV 4 or Lower Lightsworn in your grave same goes for Zombie Master
The only difference between Lumina and Zombie Master is that Zombie Master has to be face up on the field during resolution while Lumina doesn't.
Even tho the text is the same and cards should work the same, again Konami has beaten logic
The only difference between Lumina and Zombie Master is that Zombie Master has to be face up on the field during resolution while Lumina doesn't.
Even tho the text is the same and cards should work the same, again Konami has beaten logic
Badass_Bunny- Smexy Duelist
- Posts : 2660
Birthday : 1996-04-17
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Questions from me again
Zero2Hero 2011-07-07, 08:47
Most of the stuff here is right, except for the spell one. It does count as your 1 spell per turn. It has the same effect as when someone Solemns your normal summon, you can't normal summon again.nelynel12 wrote:1) I forbidden chalice my opponent Reborn tengu. Later on that turn I destroy tengu. Will he get to special summon? Yes He will.
2)I summon reborn tengu and then a whole turn pass. On my turn my opponent use book of moon on my tengu. Can I flip up my tengu that was set? If u have not summon him this turn.. yes.
3)My opponent only have a field spell in play. Can he be able to drop Gorz? (Had to argue with someone about this a few time.) No he cannot drop gorz.
4)Explain what happen when synchro or a fusion monster return to the main deck or hand - When it is return to the deck or hand it is sent to the extra deck.
5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast. Yes it does.
6) What is the difference between Lumina and Zombie master? From what I heard Lumina don't need a lightswown monster in the grave to activate it effect. You are correct. Another difference is that Zombie master HAS to remain FACE UP during the resolution or the monster will NOT summon. With lumina, it goes trough regardless.
7)Is Scrap dragon destruction effect have a cost? Does both my card and my opponent card destroy at the same time? It is not a cost. and yes its at the same time
Cool I have royal opression on the field. My opponent use glow up bulb grave effect to summon itself. I negate it by paying 800. Does that effect count to the use only once per duel? Yes it negates it. and glow up bulb cannot activate his efefct again. BTW glow up bulb mill is not a cost.
9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien? No it does not because it was negated.
Zero2Hero- Hidden Genius
- Posts : 2557
Birthday : 1994-01-10
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Questions from me again
Kikyo Maaka 2011-07-07, 09:00
Yes, because of:kumaxtreme wrote:9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien?
1) the rule of two Shogun Shien's applying (still can only activate once per turn regardless of their number) as synchro Shien's effect is the same, and;
2) if you negate, for example, a normal summon, you can't normal summon again that turn; the negated spell/trap would still apply as your one usage per turn, as you'd have had to have used it for it to get negated to start with.
Kikyo Maaka- Posts : 31
Birthday : 1993-03-09
Join date : 2011-07-02 -
Re: Questions from me again
mysticgilford101 2011-07-07, 09:46
kumaxtreme wrote:
9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien?
It does not count toward the one spell/trap for the turn. The activation was Negated, therefore it never happened.
mysticgilford101- Posts : 30
Birthday : 1989-03-14
Join date : 2011-06-23
Re: Questions from me again
Roxzen 2011-07-07, 09:48
Hmm? If that so Tengu will get it's effect once it is spun then.nelynel12 wrote:5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast. Yes it does.
Roxzen
- Posts : 1484
Birthday : 1992-04-04
Join date : 2011-05-15
Re: Questions from me again
mysticgilford101 2011-07-07, 09:53
Tengu will not activate if it is sent from the field to the deck.Roxzen wrote:Hmm? If that so Tengu will get it's effect once it is spun then.nelynel12 wrote:5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast. Yes it does.
mysticgilford101- Posts : 30
Birthday : 1989-03-14
Join date : 2011-06-23
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-07, 10:06
GUYS. you are all wrong aboutthe shien thing. Look it up. If the card is negated it does not count.
nelynel12- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
Phoenix Wright 2011-07-07, 10:34
kumaxtreme wrote:The whole purpose of this is to show proof to people who don't know the correct ruling when I'm on DN.
1) I forbidden chalice my opponent Reborn tengu. Later on that turn I destroy tengu. Will he get to special summon?
Yes
2)I summon reborn tengu and then a whole turn pass. On my turn my opponent use book of moon on my tengu. Can I flip up my tengu that was set?
I don't think so
3)My opponent only have a field spell in play. Can he be able to drop Gorz? (Had to argue with someone about this a few time.)
He cannot
4)Explain what happen when synchro or a fusion monster return to the main deck or hand
It will return to your extra deck
5) Does E-hero Absolute effect activate if it was return to the deck? Phoenix wing blast
no, its a "because konami says so" thing
6) What is the difference between Lumina and Zombie master? From what I heard Lumina don't need a lightswown monster in the grave to activate it effect.
Niether does, if you can summon what you ditch
7)Is Scrap dragon destruction effect have a cost? Does both my card and my opponent card destroy at the same time?
Its not a cost, its a targeted destruction effect, and both cards are destroyed at the same time
Nope, he can use it later
9) My opponent have the synchro Shien and the shogun shien. I activate a spell card on my turn and he negate it. Does it count toward the one card per play for shogun shien?
Nope you can still use a spell/trap
Last edited by Pox_Equestria on 2011-07-07, 15:09; edited 1 time in total
Phoenix Wright- Posts : 2772
Birthday : 1993-12-14
Join date : 2011-05-16
Re: Questions from me again
dest 2011-07-07, 11:20
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Rulings:Great_Shogun_Shien
as for Tengu:
The thing is a bit odd, the extra deck is kinda threated different then the deck. I don't know why, but it is seen in several rulings. For example, Tengu states in its rulings:
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Rulings:Reborn_Tengu
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Rulings:Elemental_HERO_Absolute_Zero
Shi En is stated here under "etc"^^If the effect of "Great Shogun Shien" is applied, when "Magic Jammer"/"Seven Tools of the Bandit"/etc negates the activation of a Spell/Trap Card, the opponent can activate one more Spell/Trap Card.
as for Tengu:
The thing is a bit odd, the extra deck is kinda threated different then the deck. I don't know why, but it is seen in several rulings. For example, Tengu states in its rulings:
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Rulings:Reborn_Tengu
And Absolute Zero states in its Rulings:This effect does not activate if Reborn Tengu is returned from the field to the Deck.
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Rulings:Elemental_HERO_Absolute_Zero
There are several other rulings which say so, but again, why the extra deck is threated so different from the deck is a book with 7 seals for me...^^If your "Elemental Hero Absolute Zero" is under your opponent's control, then when it is removed from the field and sent the Graveyard or the Extra Deck, it is sent to your Graveyard/Extra Deck, so it activates as your effect and destroys all monsters on your opponent's field.
If a face-up "Elemental Hero Absolute Zero" is removed from play from the field, its effect will activate after it is removed from play. If it is returned to the Extra Deck, its effect will activate after it is returned to the Extra Deck.
When "Elemental Hero Absolute Zero" is returned to the Extra Deck, its effect activates, and "Divine Wrath" can be chained. "Divine Wrath" will negate the effect and "Elemental Hero Absolute Zero" will be destroyed and sent from the Extra Deck to the Graveyard.
dest- Boneash
- Posts : 845
Birthday : 1987-07-30
Join date : 2011-06-29
Re: Questions from me again
catking 2011-07-07, 11:48
Deck is always random and unknown knowledge to all according to game mechanics I guess.
catking
- Posts : 14
Join date : 2011-05-18
Re: Questions from me again
kumaxtreme 2011-07-07, 14:02
There is some conflicting answers >_<
Key or a mod I need you to confirm the answer.
Another question, My opponent has chimeratech fortress dragon with 4000 atk. I use the spell card shrink on chimeratech fortress dragon. Will the monster attack be 0 permanently?
Key or a mod I need you to confirm the answer.
Another question, My opponent has chimeratech fortress dragon with 4000 atk. I use the spell card shrink on chimeratech fortress dragon. Will the monster attack be 0 permanently?
kumaxtreme- Posts : 25
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Questions from me again
dest 2011-07-07, 14:19
it wont be 0, it will be 2000 and goes up to 4000 again. Shrink affects the original attack and the original attack of fortress is 4k at that time (look carefully at its card text)
the only thing it will shrink to 0 are cards with an original attack of 0 or ? where the effect doesn't affect the original attack. (Copycat for example, there it is only an attack increase, not original attack)
the only thing it will shrink to 0 are cards with an original attack of 0 or ? where the effect doesn't affect the original attack. (Copycat for example, there it is only an attack increase, not original attack)
dest- Boneash
- Posts : 845
Birthday : 1987-07-30
Join date : 2011-06-29
Re: Questions from me again
kumaxtreme 2011-07-07, 14:25
So who is overall right about all the questions.
kumaxtreme- Posts : 25
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-07, 15:40
kumaxtreme wrote:So who is overall right about all the questions.
I am. Dest just gave you proof and he agreed with me. SO I am
nelynel12- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
Zero2Hero 2011-07-07, 15:51
Alright. You're right nelynel12. Nice work on your Rulings.
Zero2Hero- Hidden Genius
- Posts : 2557
Birthday : 1994-01-10
Join date : 2011-06-05
Re: Questions from me again
dest 2011-07-07, 15:56
yes, you are, except for that minor thing I stated herenelynel12 wrote:kumaxtreme wrote:So who is overall right about all the questions.
I am. Dest just gave you proof and he agreed with me. SO I am
Lumina is like Zombie Master in regards of the target in the grave, I only have no idea of the thing regarding being face up on the field since I can't find a ruling about that.
dest- Boneash
- Posts : 845
Birthday : 1987-07-30
Join date : 2011-06-29
Re: Questions from me again
Badass_Bunny 2011-07-07, 16:46
Nelynel12 was correct about everything except that Lumina doesn't need LS in grave to activate which dest pointed out. Period. Shi En and Shien don't make a lockdown because card has to resolve properly for it to be counted for Shien's Eff
Badass_Bunny- Smexy Duelist
- Posts : 2660
Birthday : 1996-04-17
Join date : 2011-06-12
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-07, 16:49
dest wrote:yes, you are, except for that minor thing I stated herenelynel12 wrote:kumaxtreme wrote:So who is overall right about all the questions.
I am. Dest just gave you proof and he agreed with me. SO I am
Lumina is like Zombie Master in regards of the target in the grave, I only have no idea of the thing regarding being face up on the field since I can't find a ruling about that.
I know that ruling I just made a mistake. LOl sorry
nelynel12- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
Key 2011-07-07, 20:33
If the activation is negated, the spell card is never considered to be on the field, thus you can activate another one. If the effect of the spell card is negated, you cannot activate another spell/trap
Monsters attempting to summon is different than activations of spells and traps
Extra deck and main deck have different mechanics, trigger effects relying on leaving the field does not trigger if it's sent to the main deck unless the effect specifically state so (It will mention deck)
Monsters attempting to summon is different than activations of spells and traps
Extra deck and main deck have different mechanics, trigger effects relying on leaving the field does not trigger if it's sent to the main deck unless the effect specifically state so (It will mention deck)
Key- ←↓Ruling Scrubbie↑→
- Posts : 2608
Birthday : 1994-11-29
Join date : 2011-05-21
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-07, 20:54
Key wrote:If the activation is negated, the spell card is never considered to be on the field, thus you can activate another one. If the effect of the spell card is negated, you cannot activate another spell/trap
Monsters attempting to summon is different than activations of spells and traps
Extra deck and main deck have different mechanics, trigger effects relying on leaving the field does not trigger if it's sent to the main deck unless the effect specifically state so (It will mention deck)
So key are you confirming what des and I said?
nelynel12- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
Key 2011-07-08, 02:18
Some explanations, since you've been saying it's negated while not specifying the activation or the effect.
Key- ←↓Ruling Scrubbie↑→
- Posts : 2608
Birthday : 1994-11-29
Join date : 2011-05-21
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-08, 02:19
Key wrote:Some explanations, since you've been saying it's negated while not specifying the activation or the effect.
You are right. I did not explain it well enough.
nelynel12- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
LilyRainEve(TeWe) 2011-07-08, 07:08
Can I activate multiple S/T within the same chain, while the effect of Shien is applied?add Shi En there if necessary :3
LilyRainEve(TeWe)- Posts : 29
Join date : 2011-07-08
Re: Questions from me again
nelynel12 2011-07-08, 07:10
LilyRainEve(TeWe) wrote:Can I activate multiple S/T within the same chain, while the effect of Shien is applied?add Shi En there if necessary :3
Shien effect does not chain. So if you play mst you cannot chain another magic or trap. NOW if the 1st mst was negated. Then you can play one after.
nelynel12- Posts : 583
Birthday : 1991-09-17
Join date : 2011-06-18 -
Re: Questions from me again
WrightJustice 2011-07-08, 14:05
I dunno about zombie master but I know Lumina needs a lightsworn in the grave to activate but can summon a lightsowrn that is discarded to activate the effect.
WrightJustice- Posts : 78
Birthday : 1991-08-21
Join date : 2011-06-23
Similar topics» My Box of Questions
» More questions
» Summoning questions
» Bunch of questions
» A bunch of ruling questions
» More questions
» Summoning questions
» Bunch of questions
» A bunch of ruling questions
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum|
|
|